Composting plant owner, Select Board quarrel over whether smell is nuisance at hearing
MIDDLEBORO — A stink has been made about the stink coming from A-Plus Waste & Recycling Services on River Street — enough for the town of Middleboro to make moves to shut the plant down. But during a Board of Health hearing on Nov. 16, the plant’s owner and his lawyer said there wasn’t enough evidence to call it a nuisance.
“Based on the terse letter that we received and, I would say, the short testimony from your health agent, I firmly believe that there is not enough here for this board to have issued a stop work order,” said attorney Peter Durning, who is representing Ron High, the owner of A-Plus.
High and Durning questioned the town’s reasoning for issuing a cease and desist order over the food waste odor coming from the River Street plant, and whether it followed the proper process before sending the letter. The Select Board held an executive session on Nov. 2 to discuss how to handle the issue after neighbors complained about the smell at an Oct. 26 meeting.
Despite testimony from Health Officer Eric Badger of his multiple encounters with the smell, Durning argued it wasn’t enough to be considered a public nuisance. Durning said that High had closely worked with the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection. High said that A-Plus was “the most inspected compost site in the entire Commonwealth.”
High said he had only received one compost shipment after the order was issued. Since then, he has only made a few shipments out of the facility.
High's plant receives food and organic waste to turn into compost. He said that occasional smells are part of waste management, whether at a compost and recycling facility or a landfill. “As long as there’s humans, there’s going to be waste and it has to be managed,” High said.
Durning said that on Nov. 16, before the hearing, DEP agents reported no smell. Badger said that he and another inspector reported a smell about an hour before the DEP agents arrived.
Durning said he had “serious reservations” about the process taken by the Select Board, which also serves as the town’s Board of Health. He said that there was not a clear reason for the Select Board entering executive session to discuss the matter and criticized the board for not including any expert opinion or odor samples with the letter.
Select Board Chair Teresa Farley told Nemasket Week that she consulted with town counsel before holding the Nov. 2 executive session and sending the cease and desist letter to High.
There was not enough time for public comment at the hearing, but Select Board members criticized High for not properly managing the odor. Select Board member Brian Giovanoni noted that in the 10 DEP reports Durning provided him with, a strong odor was reported twice. “I think we do have a nuisance happening 20% of the time,” he said.
Select Board member Tracie Craig-McGee called the site a “horror show” and said that she could smell the odor in her car in Halifax.
High said that he had an odor management plan that he updated annually, although he last updated it in May 2025.
High told the board multiple times that he relied on A-Plus to provide for his family. He said that he has done as much as he can to manage the smell, talking to consultants and other compost and recycling companies to find a solution.
But the Select Board felt that he hadn’t done enough. “The reason that we felt it was important to issue a cease and desist, which we all discussed, was to give you an opportunity to try to do the right thing, and nothing’s been happening for these people that live there,” Farley said.
The Select Board voted to extend the Board of Health hearing and conclude in on Nov. 23.












